Lambeth Council Chief Executive, Carole Brown Bobby Brown, Gemini Ascendant 2022, Articles H

In February 2005, North Korea claimed to possess functional nuclear weapons, though their lack of a test at the time led many experts to doubt the claim. Second, even if India wanted to, territorial conquest is impossible. [72] The United States is bound by the Hyde Act with India and may cease all cooperation with India if India detonates a nuclear explosive device. The UK tested its first atomic bomb on October 3rd, 1952. By 2018, both Russia and the U.S. had met their obligations under the New START, and in early 2021 the treaty was extended for five more years. [65] This came to fruition through a series of steps that included India's announced plan to separate its civil and military nuclear programs in March 2006,[66] the passage of the IndiaUnited States Civil Nuclear Agreement by the U.S. Congress in December 2006, the conclusion of a U.S.India nuclear cooperation agreement in July 2007,[67] approval by the IAEA of an India-specific safeguards agreement,[68] agreement by the Nuclear Suppliers Group to a waiver of export restrictions for India,[69] approval by the U.S. Congress[70] and culminating in the signature of U.S.India agreement for civil nuclear cooperation[71] in October 2008. The following is a list of states that have admitted the possession of nuclear weapons or are presumed to possess them, the approximate number of warheads under their control, and the year they tested their first weapon and their force configuration. The 2012 Deterrence and Defence Posture Review. [62] After its 1974 test, India maintained that its nuclear capability was primarily "peaceful", but between 1988 and 1990 it apparently weaponized two dozen nuclear weapons for delivery by air. Khan: Investigation, dismissal, confession, pardon and aftermath, "Pakistan to Have 200 Nuke Weapons by 2020: US Think Tank", "How the North Korean Nuclear Threat Has Grown", "TIMELINE:North Korea: climbdowns and tests", "The nuclear explosion in North Korea on 3 September 2017: A revised magnitude assessment", "North Korea has Begun Dismantlement of the Punggye-ri Nuclear Test Site', "North Korea Is No Longer Bound by Nuclear Test Moratorium, Kim Says", "North Korea declares itself a nuclear weapons state, in 'irreversible' move", "Transcript of the Director General's Interview with Al-Ahram News", "Israel's Quest for Yellowcake: The Secret Argentina-Israel Connection, 19631966", Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2017/11/Launch-Authority.pdf, https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/whose-finger-button, "Berlin Information-center for Transatlantic Security: NATO Nuclear Sharing and the N.PT Questions to be Answered", "Cossiga: "In Italia ci sono bombe atomiche Usa", Statement on behalf of the non-aligned state parties to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, "NATO's Positions Regarding Nuclear Non-Proliferation, Arms Control and Disarmament and Related Issues", "Why Ukraine gave up nuclear weapons: nonproliferation incentives and disincentives", "Post-Soviet Russia and Ukraine: Who can push the Button? The strategic forces of the Alliance, and particularly those of the United States, are the supreme guarantee of the security of the Alliance. Number of nuclear warheads belonging to NATO allies 1952-2022. The best of the best: the portal for top lists & rankings: Strategy and business building for the data-driven economy: Show sources information In the US, the Presidential Emergency Satchel is always handled by a nearby aide unless the President is near a command center. Furthermore, any employment of nuclear weapons against NATO would fundamentally alter the nature of a conflict. Since being uploaded earlier today with the title "comparison of NATO's and Russia's military strength" by user u/lestaz_ the post attracted some 70,200 upvotes and nearly 6,000 comments. Since the height of the Cold War, it has reduced the size of its land-based nuclear weapons stockpile by over 90 per cent, reducing the number of nuclear weapons stationed in Europe and its reliance on nuclear weapons in strategy . [115][116], In connection with their accession to the NPT, all three countries received assurances that their sovereignty, independence, and territorial integrity would be respected, as stated in the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances. But countries with nuclear weapons such as the US, UK, France and Russia boycotted the treaty. For its part, Russia has the most potent nuclear deterrent, at least on paper, of all states in the world. Over the last two years, . . The UK and France have said the agreement didn't take into account the realities of international security - and nuclear deterrence has been important to keeping peace for more than 70 years. These five countries are called nuclear-weapon states - and are allowed to have weapons because they . . Federation of American Scientists. The bombs get their energy from either splitting atoms or joining the tiny particles inside the atoms together. A . "Estimated number of nuclear warheads belonging to NATO allies from 1952 to 2022." Nuclear deterrence has been at the core of NATOs mutual security guarantee and collective defence since its inception in 1949. In particular, Khan had been selling gas centrifuge technology to North Korea, Iran, and Libya. The Iran nuclear deal explained in five key points, Xi Jinping's power grab - and why it matters, Street fighting in Bakhmut but Russia not in control, Russian minister laughed at for Ukraine war claims. The graphic, which had the same numbers as Statista, revealed NATO has 6,065 nuclear weapons while Russia alone has 6,255. If you are an admin, please authenticate by logging in again. The Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces has authority in North Korea. NATO is committed to arms control, disarmament and non-proliferation, but as long as nuclear weapons exist, it will remain a nuclear alliance. The Russians appear to have . The Soviet Union was the second nation to have developed and tested a nuclear weapon. It is not intended to work as a deterrent against . The remaining warheads have been retired but are still relatively intact and are awaiting dismantlement). While the Alliance focuses on the maintenance of effective deterrence, political control of nuclear weapons will be kept under all circumstances and nuclear planning and consultation within the Alliance will be in accordance with political guidance. The United States maintains absolute control and custody of their nuclear weapons forward deployed in Europe, while Allies provide military support for the DCA mission with conventional forces and capabilities. Available: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1294371/nato-nuclear-warhead-inventory/, Estimated number of nuclear warheads belonging to NATO allies from 1952 to 2022, Combined number of military personnel in NATO countries 2014-2022, Number of paramilitary personnel in NATO 2022, by country, Number of NATO troops in eastern member states 2022, Number of troops in NATO's enchanced forward presence battlegroups 2022, Combined defense expenditure of NATO countries 2014-2022, Defense expenditures of NATO countries 2022, Average defense expenditure of NATO countries as a share of GDP 2014-2022, Defense expenditures of NATO countries as a percentage of GDP 2022, Annual real change in defense expenditure among NATO countries 2014-2022, Annual real change in defense expenditure in NATO 2022, by country, Defense expenditures of NATO countries per capita 2022, Combined defense expenditures of NATO countries per capita 2022, Number of ground combat vehicles in NATO 2022, by country, Number of military ships in NATO 2022, by country, Number of military aircraft in NATO 2022, by type of aircraft, Number of ground combat vehicles in NATO 2022, by type, Number of military ships in NATO 2022, by type, Number of nuclear warheads belonging to NATO allies 1952-2022, Maximum range of operational missiles in the U.S. 2021, Support for NATO membership among member states 2021, Support for defending other NATO countries among member states 2021, Public opinion on NATO membership in Ukraine 2022, Perception of NATO application in Sweden 2022, by political party, Nuclear weapons spending of the world's nuclear armed countries 2021, Number of nuclear warheads worldwide 2022, Number of nuclear warheads deployed by the U.S. and Russia 2022, by type, U.S. nuclear weapons budget request FY 2019-2027, Number of nuclear weapons worldwide 1945-2022, Hungarians' expectations about using nuclear weapons in the Russia-Ukraine war 2022, Number of nuclear weapons worldwide 2022, by country, Number of nuclear warheads in NATO and Russia 2022, by type, British attitudes on if they should keep their nuclear weapons 2019-2022, Nuclear warhead inventory per country 1945-2022, Fear of Russia using nuclear weapons against Ukraine, Poland, and NATO countries 2022, Timeline of successful and failed ballistic missile tests by North Korea 1984-2021, Opinion on nuclear weapon necessity in Russia 2021, Nuclear warhead stockpile of the UK 1953-2022, Manhattan Project: monthly expenditure 1942-1946, Global opinion on Iran and the acquisition of nuclear weapons, 2012, Number of countries supporting the prohibition of nuclear weapons worldwide, 2017, Public opinion on North Korea having nuclear weapons in 2017, by country, Scottish opinion on nuclear weapons in Britain 2013 survey, Opinion of U.S. adults regarding the likelihood of nuclear war in next 10 years 2022, Share of U.S. adults who worry about a nuclear war with Russia 2022, Current political situation of Afghanistan 2021, Find your information in our database containing over 20,000 reports. Listen to Newsbeat live at 12:45 and 17:45 weekdays - or listen back here. This policy of "nuclear opacity" has been interpreted as an attempt to get the benefits of deterrence with a minimal political cost. France tested its first nuclear weapon in 1960 ("Gerboise Bleue"), based mostly on its own research. After World War II the U.S. had nuclear weapons stationed in Japan until the 1970s. Why Alex Murdaugh was spared the death penalty, Why Trudeau is facing calls for a public inquiry, The shocking legacy of the Dutch 'Hunger Winter'. Taiwan was developing capacities to construct nuclear weapons up until the 1970s. [citation needed], In July 2005, U.S. President George W. Bush and Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh announced plans to conclude an Indo-US civilian nuclear agreement. Since the NPT entered into force in 1970, these three states were not parties to the Treaty and have conducted overt nuclear tests. Fission bombs, also called atomic bombs, were used in the Trinity test, as were the two bombs the United States dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Japan, in August 1945. After increased tensions over the killing of Iranian General Qasem Soleimani by the US in Baghdad, Iran has said it's not going to follow the restrictions imposed by the deal anymore. Should the fundamental security of any NATO Ally be threatened, NATO has the capabilities and the resolve to impose costs on the adversary that would be unacceptable and far outweigh the benefits that any adversary could hope to achieve. The UK had provided considerable impetus and initial research for the early conception of the atomic bomb, aided by Austrian, German and Polish physicists working at British universities who had either fled or decided not to return to Nazi Germany or Nazi controlled territories. Nuclear weapons analysts estimate that the world's nine nuclear states China, France, India, Israel, North Korea . To use individual functions (e.g., mark statistics as favourites, set NATO once more outnumbered Russia with 20,700 aircraft, a factor of nearly five to one when compared to Russia's 4,170. And the bomb dropped on Nagasaki killed more than 70,000 people. To stop it, a ground-based interceptor missile fired from Vandenberg Air Force Base collided with . Of the three nuclear powers in NATO (France, the United Kingdom and the United States), only the United States is known to have provided weapons for nuclear sharing.As of November 2009, Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Turkey are hosting U.S. nuclear weapons as part of NATO's nuclear sharing policy. Video, Russian minister laughed at for Ukraine war claims. ", Federation of American Scientists, Estimated number of nuclear warheads belonging to NATO allies from 1952 to 2022 Statista, https://www.statista.com/statistics/1294371/nato-nuclear-warhead-inventory/ (last visited March 04, 2023), Estimated number of nuclear warheads belonging to NATO allies from 1952 to 2022 [Graph], Federation of American Scientists, February 23, 2022. Middlebury College provides funding as a member of The Conversation US. Most of those . Physicists have sought to influence U.S. nuclear weapons policy from the earliest days of the nuclear era, working through a variety of organizations including APS. "[Ukraine] freely gave up the world's third-largest nuclear arsenal in exchange of guarantees of its sovereignty from Russia, the U.K. and the U.S.". Even though these countries have nuclear weapons, under the agreement, they have to reduce how many they have and can't keep them forever. Russian President Vladimir Putin issued a chilling warning to Western nations after saying it is "not a bluff" that he may turn to nuclear weapons. States that formerly possessed nuclear weapons are South Africa (developed nuclear weapons but then disassembled its arsenal before joining the NPT)[13] and the former Soviet republics of Belarus, Kazakhstan, and Ukraine, whose weapons were repatriated to Russia. The graphic, which appeared to draw from a similar comparison list by Statista, revealed NATO allies had superiority over Russia in most areas of military strength. . Putin annexed Crimea in 2014 and has announced referendums in Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson. The U.S . Now these "ambassadors against nuclear weapons" are fighting for disarmament - and have stopped in Hamburg on their round-the-world boat trip. What's the least amount of exercise we can get away with? How does NATO respond to the threat of nuclear weapons? [57][58] China acceded to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in 1992. However, since all U.S. nuclear weapons are protected with Permissive Action Links, the host states cannot easily arm the bombs without authorization codes from the U.S. Department of Defense. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (Nato) alliance was founded in 1949 to bring countries together to avoid nuclear warfare. The Nuclear Planning Group provides the forum for consultation on NATOs nuclear deterrence. The US dropped an atomic bomb on the Japanese city of Hiroshima on 6 August 1945, A mushroom cloud which is an effect of a nuclear explosion, Iran's President Hassan Rouhani has previously said they would not pursue nuclear weapons, The leader of North Korea, Kim Jong-un, says North Korea has missiles which can reach the US, Russian minister laughed at for Ukraine war claims. North Korea reported a successful nuclear test on 9 October 2006 (see 2006 North Korean nuclear test). Many of those missiles can be equipped with multiple nuclear warheads that can independently hit different locations. [1] Five are considered to be nuclear-weapon states (NWS) under the terms of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). Arms control, disarmament and non-proliferation in NATO, Resilience, civil preparedness and Article 3, NATOs annual nuclear exercise gets underway, NATO Secretary General addresses annual Nuclear Policy Symposium, NATO Declassified: Documents related to the Non-Proliferation Treaty are publicly disclosed, NATO Secretary General marks 50 years of UK submarine nuclear deterrent, Chairman of NATO Military Committee visits key UK strategic deterrent site, NATO policy makers discuss deterrence and nuclear policy, North Atlantic Council visits UK strategic nuclear forces. After the end of the Cold War in 1991 and the breakup of the Soviet Union - of which Ukraine was part - large numbers of nukes were left behind in Ukraine by Moscow. So just how many nuclear weapons does Russia have? [73] In establishing an exemption for India, the Nuclear Suppliers Group reserved the right to consult on any future issues which might trouble it. Profit from the additional features of your individual account. North Korea claimed to have conducted its first hydrogen-bomb test on 5 January 2016, though measurements of seismic disturbances indicate that the detonation was not consistent with a hydrogen bomb. And now European countries have challenged Iran for not following the terms of the deal. He works for CNS as a Graduate Research Assistant. Khan denied complicity by the Pakistani government or Army, but this has been called into question by journalists and IAEA officials, and was later contradicted by statements from Khan himself. This crash project was developed partially with information obtained via espionage during and after World War II. It was also relevant to retain great power status, alongside the United Kingdom, during the post-colonial Cold War (see: Force de frappe). [53] As of 2016, China fielded SLBMs onboard its JL-2 submarines. Chronicling the Spread of Nuclear Weapons, Discussion Paper (Cambridge, MA: Project on Managing the Atom, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, June 2017). How many nuclear weapons does Russia have? While the US helped negotiate the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, the Senate rejected the treaty in 1999. You only have access to basic statistics. Three reasons behind Trump ditching Iran deal, US-made cheese can be called 'gruyere' - court, Harry: I feared losing memories of mum during therapy, AOC under investigation for Met Gala dress, The children left behind in Cuba's exodus, Alex Murdaugh's legal troubles are far from over, Saving Private Ryan actor Tom Sizemore dies at 61, Nelson's 97th-minute stunner gives Arsenal victory. All Allies, with the exception of France, which has decided not to participate, are members of the NPG. They also happen to be the UN Security Council's (UNSC) permanent members with veto power on UNSC resolutions. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. The UK's independent nuclear deterrent is relevant not only for today, and it will remain an important part of our national security strategy for as . In contrast to past years, when some . The 9K720 Iskander missile system, known to NATO forces as the SS-26, is capable of delivering "tactical" nuclear weapons as well as standard explosive warheads. Can Nigeria's election result be overturned? However, this is the first time APS has released a report on the subject since 2013. Juni 2020, Odstraszanie nuklearne dzisiaj - 8 czerwca 2020, - 8 2020, Bugnk Nkleer Caydrclk - 08 Haziran 2020, - 8 2020, European security without the INF Treaty - 30 September 2019, The Nuclear Weapons Ban Treaty: reasons for scepticism (NATO Review, 18 May 2017), Nuclear deterrence and the Alliance in the 21st century (July 2016). [74] As of May 2021, India was estimated to have a stockpile of around 160 warheads. Nine countries currently have nuclear weapons: the US, UK, Russia, France, China, India, Pakistan, Israel and North Korea. While the sheer size of both Russia and NATO's military forces attracted concern, it was the nuclear arsenals that drew the most comments from users. The alarming statement comes as Ukraine continues its counteroffensive on Russian-occupied territory within its borders. The 82 single-warhead missiles the state had . In wartime, allied planes would take off from those locations and fly toward their targets before dropping the bombs. [78] In 1998, Pakistan conducted its first six nuclear tests at the Ras Koh Hills in response to the five tests conducted by India a few weeks before. [8], According to the Natural Resources Defense Council and the Federation of American Scientists, Israel likely possesses around 80400 nuclear weapons. ", "Calls for Olmert to resign after nuclear gaffe Israel and the Middle East", "SIPRI: Number of fatalities caused by armed conflict falls in 2020", "Here's how many nuclear warheads exist, and which countries own them", "Global Nuclear Arsenal Declines, But Future Cuts Uncertain Amid U.S.-Russia Tensions", "The Nuclear Club: Who are the 9 members?". [90][91][92][93][94][95][11] Israel is not a party to the NPT. In, Federation of American Scientists. It has been signed by the UK and US as well as the Soviet Union (now Russia), and in total 191 countries have now joined the treaty. Directly accessible data for 170 industries from 50 countries and over 1 million facts: Get quick analyses with our professional research service. The test was the first test developed after the creation of the NPT, and created new questions about how civilian nuclear technology could be diverted secretly to weapons purposes (dual-use technology). On Sunday, Putin declared that his country's nuclear forces were to be put into special "combat readiness.". Chinas nuclear arsenal is currently similar in size to the U.K. and French arsenals. South Africa produced six nuclear weapons in the 1980s, but dismantled them in the early 1990s. Nuclear weapons: how many are there in 2009 and who has them? During that time the United States stationed some of their arsenal in Taiwan. [49], The United Kingdom tested its first nuclear weapon ("Hurricane") in 1952. [89], Israel is widely believed to have been the sixth country in the world to develop nuclear weapons, but it has not acknowledged its nuclear forces. The decision rests with the Prime Minister in the United Kingdom. Read about our approach to external linking. The U.S. State Department said it made it "very clear that we will not recognize India as a nuclear-weapon state". Vasilii Tuganov receives funding from the Institute of International Education as a Fulbright Visiting Graduate Student and Edmund Muskie Professional Fellowships program participant. The SPD and the Green election platforms demanded the removal of the U.S. bombs from German soil. Please do not hesitate to contact me. The Deterrence and Defence Posture Review (DDPR) was endorsed by Allied Heads of State and Government at the NATO Chicago Summit in May 2012. Of those, about 2,000 in both countries can be . However, Canada withdrew three of the four nuclear-capable weapons systems by 1972. Both Russia and the U.S. have thousands of nuclear weapons, most of which are five or more times more powerful than the atomic bombs that leveled Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945. The Reddit user posted: "Ukraine is the lesson for what happens to a nuclear-free country who minds their own business. Was India misled by America on nuclear deal? The number of nuclear weapons in the world is actually down from 70,000 in 1986 to around 14,000 today. In theory, pretty much anyone with the technology, intelligence and facilities. Russia grants such power to the President but may also require approval from the Minister of Defence and the Chief of the General Staff; weapons can also be launched using the automated Dead Hand system. How many nuclear weapons does Russia have? In particular, under the Strategic Offensive Reductions Treaty thousands of Russian and U.S. nuclear warheads are inactive in stockpiles awaiting processing. ", "The Budapest Memorandum and U.S. The answer is, no. February 2020 Public Diplomacy Division (PDD) - Press & Media Section Tel. Also, how many nuclear weapons exist, who has them, and how powerful are they? Read about our approach to external linking. Get full access to all features within our Business Solutions. About half of the roughly 200 U.S. shorter-range weapons are believed to be deployed in five NATO countries in Europe: Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Turkey - though the U.S. does . It's impossible to measure the cost of the war to the Ukrainian people, but it can be argued that, for the U.S, spending $100 billion vs the $6.5 trillion we spent in Iraq and Afghanistan has . This is because of something called the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) - an agreement which aims to prevent the spread of nuclear weapons and promote disarmament. Pakistani Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto promised in 1971 that if India could build nuclear weapons then Pakistan would too, according to him: "We will develop Nuclear stockpiles, even if we have to eat grass."[76]. This led to an agreement in 2015 between Iran and other big powers, in which Iran signed a deal to scale back its nuclear energy programme in exchange for trade, but President Donald Trump pulled out of the deal in May 2018. China, France and the U.K. are not subject to any arms control treaties. In October 2006, North Korea stated that, in response to growing intimidation by the United States, it would conduct a nuclear test to confirm its nuclear status. The US has more than 5,500. NATOs current nuclear policy is based on two public documents agreed by all Allies: The 2022 Strategic Concept, adopted by Allied Heads of State and Government at the NATO Summit in Madrid sets out the Alliances core tasks and principles, including deterrence. The Sinpo is the smallest ballistic missile submarine today and, aside from China's Type 032 test boat, the only one that is diesel-powered. Israel is also generally understood to have nuclear weapons,[3][4][5][6][7] but does not acknowledge it, maintaining a policy of deliberate ambiguity. Senior Fellow, James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies, Middlebury, Graduate Research Assistant at James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies, Middlebury. That's also why a nuclear bomb is sometimes called an atomic bomb. His troops are on the defensive in Ukraine and those close to the Kremlin leader have accused the UK of being and "aggressor". As of 2023, Russia has about 5,977 nuclear warheads, an estimated 1,500 awaiting dismantling, 2,565 deployed strategic warheads and 466 Intercontinental ballistic . The system has been in place since 1969, and can only be activated by the Prime Minister - currently Liz Truss - even if it is deployed as part of a NATO action. This agreement has been violated by Russia since the Russo-Ukrainian War began in 2014, during which Russia annexed Crimea, occupied Eastern Ukraine, and in 2022, invaded the remainder of the country with no direct response. NATO's goal is a safer world for all; the Alliance seeks to create the security environment for a world without nuclear weapons. NATOs goal is a safer world for all; the Alliance seeks to create the security environment for a world without nuclear weapons. The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons has been in place since 1970. After the Cold War, France has disarmed 175 warheads with the reduction and modernization of its arsenal that has now evolved to a dual system based on submarine-launched ballistic missiles (SLBMs) and medium-range air-to-surface missiles (Rafale fighter-bombers). "[108] The Institute of Strategic Studies Islamabad (ISSI) has criticized the arrangement for allegedly violating Articles I and II of the NPT, arguing that "these Articles do not permit the NWS to delegate the control of their nuclear weapons directly or indirectly to others. Its first thermonuclear weapon was tested in 1951, and its most recent nuclear weapon test was . Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. [104] This involves pilots and other staff of the "non-nuclear" NATO states practicing, handling, and delivering the U.S. nuclear bombs, and adapting non-U.S. warplanes to deliver U.S. nuclear bombs. The Indian position has also asserted that the NPT is in many ways a neo-colonial regime designed to deny security to post-colonial powers. In order of acquisition of nuclear weapons, these are the United States, Russia (the successor of the former Soviet Union), the United Kingdom, France, and China. The remaining 1,150 weapons are held by seven . Today There Are Regrets. Both nations nuclear arsenals also include hundreds of shorter-range nuclear weapons, which are not covered by any treaty. Eight sovereign states have publicly announced successful detonation of nuclear weapons. Chart. In July 2017, it looked as though the world was a step closer to becoming nuclear weapon free when more than 100 countries endorsed a UN treaty to ban them altogether. [103], Nuclear weapons have been present in many nations, often as staging grounds under control of other powers. The first nuclear-powered submarine was built by the US in 1954. South Africa could not have constructed such a nuclear bomb until November 1979, two months after the "double flash" incident.